Ident compering

I have been set the task to compare two idents by BBC1(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X2QN8ff-a9o&feature=player_embedded) and BBC2(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OTO8UIgFp2U&feature=player_embedded). Both of these indents are good in there own right and have meaning that is metaphorical shown that represents the channel and what its about, BBC1's ident shows a person in the rain riding a bike then it shows him being joined by other people and they all ride the same way and end up on a circle and the weather goes from rainy to sunny and shows the BBC1 logo, watching this ident says to me that when one person is alone other people will come along with you and the people are different colors that represents different races and it shows when we all come together it brightens up the day and makes the world go round because we are all together and bring color and sun to each of our lives which is what BBC1 wants to show it does; to show itself as a family channel because it shows programs for all ages and races. BBC2's ident shows a view of a futuristic world then zooms out to revile the BBC2 logo and shows the view was being shown with a zoetroupe, watching this indent says to me that BBC2 is a channel thats shows future programs but still keeps its old style because it shows programs about modern or future things but if mainly for a older audience and that its a channel that has come along way from when it was launched. Overall I think that both idents are great and have a good meaning behind them that describes the channel well but I like BBC1's indent more because I can relate to it more and my view may be like this because I am a youth but if I were older then I might have seen BBC2 differently but both channels have programs for a wide rang of audiences but they are split into different tribes.